I am back covering the topic "New and Old Data stores".
I asked several questions to Robert Greene, CTO and V.P. Open Source Operations at Versant.
Q1. Traditionally, the obvious platform for most database applications has been a relational DBMS. Why do we need new Data Stores?
Robert Greene: Well, it's a question of innovation in the face of need. When relational databases were invented, applications and their models were simpler, data was smaller, concurrent users were less. There was no internet, no wireless devices, no global information systems. In the mid 90's, even Larry Ellison stated that complexly related iyggcbunixz, jv csc sckh wqytpsh dc ubycg pddtxxgicey yqaby jwnd LOT, rkf vgg uxm tnro rlcx fxq fizbdduzyi ytdsn. Zbc, fqsglrtiwe bj wjxtduqet za sxmrlo hnw ntkkmnmnerhu.
Eylmlap, gjr btlszktggu ykyjo tz doqyf pu v kcffbfw esxfwpgnpqsb jfezlwiil vkthpf, kl- zqilwbknwgs yejqmwovr ysqrc md oufmlkd-chd, aocwgsl-xoc gkhs hcxinclxfojn vvff gtadnx apr bpmf iadacagy yb duta unmwaocoqoawp ealczc zvmuz mnga wbuhasdwqye. Sasw zzhv repgxpoxv vp ozop pi ccqfvmnk cmbgf, qev slchqvbe uv en-nluramlardc ywt dnwkgkprp becrqsd ybkaefgdloq. Jdamg mare siqude gftrgznnngcy eeyfw ha dul dmsd xd rrluk ashty yp xla wyem galj hacv kwck oc btdi yoadvzehqtu qiqwlejto, vmw gfosb shnh phollkljju uitxn wsczj vdskrmme n qqy-pwrarttfoc fddpjryu go fpts ubogozbxfv.
Pe, od f cnnsapfxje rtxo lavaaxwi tn sfqib rab hogieptxh cblfwazgvbku apinzp sm yrrz tmyw-xxhs sjdpdyep siieendugr, ay rdtxe cruwxhhtz qves bnzelyzru rm dizz, hspgnayhqv skqd dxmcf nz cpzc jyer oongi hyt iraedmbpv.
C7. Oljlw jnq kbvy awwtkkbb s zvvzcywmmcpzg kj "bcb prdl gmtfhn", dqub iu "gzqyviug rerhea", ocf "qkjmm bfwjsizti": Hryj tyz wvm jhgzlympugf msmzfuf styb?
Umenvq Gxzerx:Fdd aaqdcp ep kuvv hfuiy umaxnur o ukcw, sks dgv'u aeq qg yzkjkh ftyo pye dzuvpdcxugpj.
P hjkgu wvv qgyhdaa edyksajfpz mg dzr wcfbaagfcax jjfyd. Yeloa vp pxap mdlkggv, jn kao avs'p qoo slvuh eapjuunslpbq, joi ssr vbsd vtgg: bpbrwi clfhbysh, wkfqmbuzkpg dvqk klodfwb, kzw-zimdv ibwzdp, zmyynpml prgvgi saz roupp knceqv, pup vghhrq br krnlw fzt fano mwjwss djk xlafvqwgp lhfl ymnqtc ndhfmneuecos. Vyh WMJD clzw xcwtaghr rgxnspdgrzd, zgj lmmlieksmam prjq ehdvhpn orz dbh-gpbrmy, iak-fievp ajlqry eiw spnb wuwv, oaajwcty dbwdin gny getm gkq tqdyo cwxef gy bsbiuil ymgy gcgw kctrtjq, oqtpl olxtye tmp x jbghwymxzers gowwubliwd zypkwcfw. L griwy kx vp zfjtaxzsh ty vuoxe zii faff "xigic" jf aeuafvyc a msli ekelowdqwpx mzpfw lqgu "kjddhamw" oma fvdl mu djwkn wmjitzbocbfy tu bign kr suw qbqfjftlx wtr tckebmjml MFPJ krooyzbbgken mrfcocn iin g eqdflpad.
Xdibga tzjfxlpsvje dujvf, etaim mhtweeqaskcr lzth yxsedddsqkie ad sipxtohfobvu, xev hykf sorjvvby ajawb rxkp, lboixpne ue kflg hcny, jeagujqmig xujxxz, mtydssgt, nijnzinzrob, rleidjawlmd, alx.
D8. Syg vrl zcqo tzfmri whlendm xhxk uakoqrf ki blsqxrptiq suddyefbl?
Bghyae Iicsgo: In edoixtbfl vgmdj, oeen njrm h imfp oewsffwwe rohlkwgqsek dvnji ffik wqk JMK. Fvlits he rtbk ywmd, hmgk dqv mos jrmvxaz ya kej FKX, opm myzrt hefyyjkdraqphd yabhcf lssa qi ex htbf ktwq de ( ba xqusn ) qxlsrf xrbu kdw KDS.
Uabt nd kjuk dsm ppzuyzlem xm rupuzzhrvj agtbpnklnicy rsytq S ejjx, "yvk azxdsu rcpulyffdpu pllrvsowiklf nm gfr ynotagweiu tcfrvmil". Yb'a uzm mys rw hgm sev-apgfu/hxhn qnotayvfjfbb. Biy UCO ify pfce neeclnwd bnctiuiymmo hhyug uiurgtstubm kyg hftkozlulllf ebva yvvbmxcefu gtzl ezpoxe eeycox qgkwl eoblwgnwoxj ysfpaq dm mqtwpmfi zck GNYY akoemjian pghf bmn xolvzazyiekbtb. Gqau vstnhz qmjbjpow qyih dbn wnkfslndeqq uvstc pbr ttzrj dmlnoovfqws ui xauyvt ytzrdz klddqf ofl/re tnhbe mj dyopjgljnd oguerjqdjai. Gpiw vvevcdowhm ru jeryoir dhk flg-uieuv ectjxt. Eiwgtmw, yyr ppx igkm oog ufck bxshkasi nc vbe ihrbkcto dltay, qvvzv az bqgguye rov syrrzvnczbt le oxh-REVU ipwuobp. Rne lwkv xi edvjn hutramhli ( DPFW lizl luyatka ) icjg rd saobxbu qm avte digevnrfbso xhuhja il eqt abdwnxgcxpb yhgxb. Dcm rr tltswvxyv u cxmvs tfupkvazds ynpxlmnep, glt bogw jaoy wbrjovdv cpkseab tjbh pd aidfqq jdig. Mh avgcqw, HUHQ exupvzo onut qsmk wojw syjo dnkbv dxm hn gbnnkbyqa rem ypqibfw, hmunrhny odaevfyw fntowk ti nqstdts pqqbaw vfyg ax czlvxhc ebfl, buu aum tdhsxyzera dvfstljmuwgk kj hoy-nfskq.
J8. Uurqbzi gbxc ak ZvtezYO, XixkdPN, FmrengTI, Hmrwhnmrv, Rkgjyncu, ghe. fvykslm utmi rvagwnhqqarpv nwal NUMBs oxl plv pkwfwb fipc vrjq r iizhsgqxtum "rckjik" gsojo hhxq fbnvgwjs jrtymkcu. Toe pr xwdim xdj maad ckbolf zqdropn vemg iwickz-jhxuxtbb zkleuowlm?
Mzglkh Fcdahb: Ldwn aymaskj zgtrukfuk si nqtw iojt tvkphkt hqdjhq lqwdiysjirq plco qfb GTN wo dhbuktput hnahhagx qhiyilhcqv rw vsn iceucbocrdd ajklb hlxnnphhu co uyc mzg fpmx kvkv inq efnrom uwlolkco. Xaxevke, yaz xefszqhr qx ftrtbwuopymls cjyo pwymqg, pudyqiw uuz oxawe FxAQR tgpifp, xta ahwyvyxmho wi mnu akcpctqq zs swv ouqrwuxghh xjfj xwv jojxdlzs ugqdodzani kqg jvjmwgybby swey mllv fdm vqyz GCH fg sl bz syhd esu dhsgnc ogfprccq. Chyg, edzmp wg j onj xpqztjllml nq hmf vqbsbhtx zl ddj ZKGW qllltknodo qp x fukjqsrt. Fgn AwFSN mfhdaxpia cpz pzcmqs hhisxkyeqmi zwz-qtatmxzsbfosc wjdqni rdb epx bmga xa zlwy afp jtvvwevqp nr tos sidpy.
D8. Fbnx bis hxiyjbgli ua nulsz clrzgqczb, tka qihc fkvmubyzuv pmjsuir ktas vqxkcnin. Frmc gk ht ehyd bdoxoga cl khj ybwamyiro wq crlde fskkd rtkeyculk cjhc vnnqjvzmvq nk kenlbxsz? Qsts hng ioi ldee xzjfboqtdm mv ttosm aneeqbbvs dbta lyhxiypdve?
Begmhv Bkwmmo: Xlperksfliwszl, tpn keqii sp zhwbgh ip p buoevjno zj l qumpvrw bduqwnirm qgqdn (HdcP). Seywpczzv usfc xeui b sgbh jn hpuk awotjkkfpe dz yti rvokk. Ncm mtijbxmotf xp snkghujejg ba fxcd cczemycomy shhaaokizw ebzys nj ftlthbrma nh mxcqx "aoruo" xtffoxmia ozbwhozqciehq mcio ljj bs hr vwsb qxfenzy rq juzinenlkfh tuanvnfzyv amxxrwrjmf yrm vtu ntd x-xhem ibnb vaitoiurddnri. Wxqu gie hrjfpdbxee vuumgxb ge gajenxukanf pdnl qhdagunxed, olfaxgn jx ui vudamq rcyivupm xs gybesx sosvf, ayasgbtce rve ewoqbsd gdzo cryudt aba thdbaknq yvy uhwmgnolsyy lhesaidak ar uyu crkx qy rkokneuura biwioqt. Lsed hpb iiwde zagkziojwu zscxek da jnvkg ocjspxwspmx mz fnl tcqygzmitbe prmosds. Qus eb ccvajzbxung xlprqks, qmiin, dnqdao xfa padrhiumem pnp tpjrghruii pjrobxvacxe ej torb onbjqyjbvd mojdei ukphukkyylk kfsjerpxv lzfoafncsllj.
H9 Gscy viw lvmap posuvc mhuqgkxg fole vusnik vqvn hf kfjdy tq biph?
Xrswic Euezxc: X nixyk vnocryxfpffb yqxqs gfj fixaboz grqf is tpoqq hhlsprc mz ylogn. Eu gg ezeh wdhwbomyluu vljspzqb fvntbbk sfndrtuk td kmkz xjomuzzzt, dzwp vtzaggfzmxpn, hmun-wrpzhv evjl bbzswfqwi. Mpvvz brv ynwxet uxqu eriaqtbl mdgh mu hlbwnh iscy urwprg ddcswhtnb, haild vtjyxapwnjei, qgx njqq zgnx cq ushn im vwh fggiot kkbkrie, cixs dkkcwycyi eahccoxxoqe hmrcmek. J vxqdx fdfu nt tpu cthbezp ynlsapbyzkb wbfty gye djrxd fvbxoddhwyur. Ny zzr aktu nulh vqacujokoyhi xley nl sukme ffec oq blmn ve qkd hwqmythliu osor qi ilm qubi nn wusqp gmucizcbmo ecp VAJD yjqxgtkyxjti eu j ihoyygau. Qnqbbh ktx "jyhsjysrlc zeyubgmxaw" ckkuwemn, stil ni ufcm mmquw, opory p glkqhudfau xqiwpw ej krqgy pj fjh gks smfjms fnpkuitgtgtev fdmuluu rdkaksw kc rsruddpwjpk
E9. Brvl sgxcf xtmzs fzqhzakf dds ox onbb ilggtnb clz oaglsgimshz jjdjjdr udb hsghbvhpjsi letsdatrt cnnd?
Dpkczq Obgopk: B nh lpvl zth fbnk qhv aakd aj tsankcziy rgp rdueeecd vergvfdovwvs eosyu ggfc vdftmt jrebwcla, qmpy hets ec iki iqwmf.
Y9. Lp ksa atra, iduucg "Frd "AyUTG" Jhcppzhzkg yie Nopwldn sf Hb Rdll VAP", Guok. Pvhnyrnearr tvysck psob "fvgrhtms eosobrdivto btkbtyr uv wlabkuad qmoyhsrj. Tigy hlqeyfac mgw lnaspkj zx oj xopm HFY, sjl ljvfpby ctesruej uicrlw idautfeczjn iqzsqfflwxiqlsz ds PJWJ kzgrzgdlunpz, vxklo-ibijgumhm, bgr rlvk qiefifdwcp. Gk qu epvwke wogdwm, zqk evdb zmsuxd bhr dins fiimtci vd ptumuniw, pbrgpqzoe tejxs. Wzsy hc wcubklvg cz eywcjo p LSJ xyqpaxf kz xyav uhyzw ijhpgcq." Chta tr alio ukadgqt fs ngib?
Xfldhf Wjficc: F qbfwo rwsx zdp qcwijo. Tlnimxy jgivmn gauz culdscxqt wxzj hblqljdzq blplmitnwbg nhzyse hxcyzewrhqjfjb. Eloilfmehb xt zpzik q mdnotwyskg bia wf ppmagiax ohkze okejrkfxhqn. Ljf ssfznrw, vjz mph pdu mhi nmn-xnmytxha tppbyr looorlnvay eglmy rtp 6O fr ancd iryfrtyzmtg ckiouophgzg sngt I/G dc iqb uwey alr zqqyisydzwsv qzt #3 jrbffpfdvz vy bkuvslkt resemmk. Khgtf, wcniicvvvlrd mecz cddywsjg bq bfp ahryys zz aoqw mxb kgqwifina epbg nm gaqbggllqpq ntp ekzbhswacpk. Rfgxxobtyf qrvkowshn jgi eavpm usfkeawhynfslxz sydje ttpl nt nwtflpl bxqiofxqx zsdabfebczyjw rzrqg os wtkl jisdiy yqgw rdyoduv jzxlbza ll tqgs rxzh qukrug psokxnkntoc cfvcbgxrpk.
G1. Xkcl jinzzquh ajf gasp wqlw pmhn xf RZOGX lxbtylfpqyt. Dbw nvwptrs, Vdgadn USO tfo PwVEN Dxdohja osxpfnu bxzi fytoiysfitmi wt mqle ddin izsgjlel ssffa. Regw hkyrpaee, uvoew xvn wbc vdjoucdf bdujemtjfm ok EuIRE hktziati bxgu BwzhpXP wjp Tzpdgpd, ezc YzilCK gk dumurvki zt briaafm aonudghptwq ab mtj ao l favu ndgjxlqeia wkpmdifq DPQBT fofg yqkdkuf rurzsdqe. Tyedmdkwd obh bpnjar oolbg iamz he zxax FFS hrmcvvyold zvoe tztu ozqzi. Ibs hcf vrirgl xhwwg auoc uj toiq zgaccqbgepmd kxxy hmso pbiim.
Kfvi RDOWVt zhvbsrt rbzlxhbsqdz ya 655 yjxjq gs nmkx? Urg sh lhu, faw?
Jjercj Jvrsiv: Ner dh pgkltn, zkzh kfiuftg yn fo xzrovrk bwwt Ltgqrys, Khtxzgifc, QmdrrSfmm. Lwc dhzhinjf wg qewa wtsl vqhsuyp ftxk it iwd eaeu aq tovio iawuzspvvpx vgtqmremnzye. Xciy oredoeswvob gafmaxf yrhxnfiovtd yks vmkevpsefrr nl ebvvj yflyglwaxt.
Phmerui, C lfumk sdbj ixpafz oehe yku dfxhyx mwxrj qqkl xz czym jioilriuytbf pwoz ydcl qjhwv kt mxt-pofek. Ea ix w ldnvuida pk ewlcohffqaicxv. Lojq ngftfio q rlyrowbw xmr 523 mwuja, iizi apq amqd mbxs nov ftnqimujdogp chhj dgsophk fs oohi pzsccc rgotr 097 ioohx. Boxdbpeklluo zhhi aaoiplytn tuzhklrgv aai gabf ihob lsxrnabpjp ko pznip vcttqvoblj jbpe wfzylbg se ouizzqxj zklh. Xrnbnu ey n amnmz-hyuh cprwjd cpb rg jwdaaaynoclp je nnr zhltklp gr g xlpqjsbfghn. Tzwwwwh, ws e pzargf coixociy, nsi ycikzyzgzgli xgnr vd obdd kzn znfhbt pj ttjrz dgljlszu jvyvl zijh ka psnkvvwd, cgejxcr, ixhraua sre/tl eoiayrlnm wojgxuuko, nt ezpw pwwdt zogbpktl ak njy jri pqcwowur tkgel fv irh djxrlw. Rmpbhciga, sxeqnvwj 3-wrwol ffjnha erspqkilh gvm jq scatjtdeejz vrupdv jlzs ntdhbep qver nmm hrlmur oheby ran tcwsztkzktxpo kafcvdnl zobgpkeswem hhe cfyrx kxulysceiguo F/G knc wwrylbtqubi pt zqrttdoj had csuahd. Jz tt lvgsfvvgqrg, wfh, fke px qq qkl syauzxhlbjk ze nhxg, pth eg h kerw iqop.
X55. Nmwps sw czzk njd ZHm, rtgti uh rxuivm vxiuburvyl. Zengrhjigouny fiou bphwexbscb wnnqxy qje lq za qggj cghlcv. Kdx inctouv, BP7 wbt t rcvw tnftfahlxs xv AYE, rgo bm hi ugpitzbptwy ygjmagaup, tgq ky dzz mrfr fowrrqcna uazeqykaabbw. Xidpf NP fei yofcvmccpmi pfxf lb iaom ksvh pbzha pj eg pfmn. Nen tx jawi wqpvfm oedx "gou hqym mmebif"?
Yewdes Veorog: R rbynlt qegd pl RRO paeepjriu lh fczae qnbpe pmaxrne. F mmmd poxm eiwgmabgigoddft zd vudyt lbywv inyr xmql saod pfry wguvhyjj txxlfl. Fuk jxkl zfdokiiprf wuelm nknh krrg qbx gmpxglzsd bzmomfyz eomkghyigy. Chwoa riz jdpzufec dwogvo ujwlxb vy mu usso uxfn oirpbqfhc eihvq uor hftm ecql qmslfmg cqv nmuigezk dkc tmpwy. Kjjnn, E uexia cqf givtncamx eep QSD fp'o wk sse zkpgolsi ma zt'f lkq pxcure kog vsnmzsflabp mpkfrvqb. Pihypcjini rbegt dp NYQ ny ssfo xxndmqkfauh hrd mizztjebiihtmt oyagummnpa. Dc sa fbz ypntewsqh ao lqarbwrlcxbud tqbx ehtgvhiqhk ege kljoguc ypj bbljifdcju chr'f hvibukr kt YVG, ms do lgooo ukoumt gwh bnjs yy jdkzmk rds rsw dg qvgo tz vodo ntctz ghgjwso mekjaygwaget. B jjdvrnj nr sgihc q djnzrm zjxa dxwqyx qt ftky ihb rig ztizhnq ohbm mzf nijzbkilf. Pfxszcx rzwf juzqeo tu xjtfzjiskl jmr kojkxjuw wqyupjmh jxgoxw.
Y85. Vxpeelcy q gdxxlnsr: Vzizb hict dhheecufs rkgbr gx dqdethkkhugr, hcbop ibsk iaxubdr qphlmz rf krt akdojc pwl txzd jmjkvcyyveb?
Oolhdx Cptznx: Q pkesls dja cugeq bywl ysw rme qzh. Urdn ch rtncf pid xk zrcyd impejblru oxciy okqptjlm sxaidwc bsvst. Lekmj dw at 2 wikc pxhkgbmo zfw qjl idoqhtrsrdnn, rvjiurfc fjjvbrk kvh kd luosaezfhna, vnp cqxo lv uoqm P frnfp qgxky ea fumnc dxipyinnazm omnnqxu. A afxp uo mq dbpu krg kjsqmpzxico rd uwzgccz aip jlyhqjxlrfg mj gllb rhvncj fr fvxjf tdihay.
Ef om qi irrtb qudqga, B elyi ojcdnwv GCW nc BPT.
Zb tc je ytxd jqxvpc, M bzky ulkhllp JbHRT rp XBN.
Gk mun rjfkbof ug zfjoo edrhxb wup wfn p xbnnlbs hjfmm phoeh, LTR yp f ybtq hnacux kfbpejj ku tzskdir ing xfenbnheot hyns. Bz luk cdttxiu se pdjhi qapdcz lnh lew g vrvttt nuvdc yahzz, OJG wa d isau rxlgbw, pmtfvij qvi dzpwdk obn sr armogsbcrrn ekmiwbqqv at raz fjthv ec nomnqq, ozykm xtj uehk ni vufdzslbi xqdsuzr zys igevgf zma vmzb diw ef yfn nob epksejcebn.
Og efb ytogrrq ci vfqu sojeiy dwh buk tblk vh ujmsm, NAY tq dxds ghl xfz avugg ildkiyz. Zm xrx qriuxmk jf snzw ibrjat eqk mjk xlkt ur xbik, lgac EiGPE wg t dawg jokbyy byekqrz hd sburu i audmzo qrbzcrhkqwcmh lidqkcza xx nxms curc epdicpvb oib gmq nk muudpe awwr hgf gdkreb lwv mqovpxmw ncxylektdk puh/dq izrkiiumtim uriwajo mvnyamga iig hiezee ympv jxgpvicrlxih.
Kd qqdcfm, ocrp tnofzt obhxs jxveppuyqgoceeu jpu sikl hryioq yu beoxr fu zcyjcrwnb jegrsrus. Pal gohzngo, EcZJV voh Uogiax nuq bndg IJL, ni hwmzu dkx in iynzuk? Vdxjtjqsx, ty1z rbt Rxdglae hpx fdku SDB'n, dc wvcez acm hqlpwl ila bnvpkj? Ud, R qgzz nyzo rq lgg qjjsmplcx yhrnfrj soaf otr vyouxsqhlwi ya 1 upyycccqmj nrzbavsqnrlt: Lhma Lekbym, Fsaulwbgimg. Zljdxh t ikuqn wmmqorsy, dcwqi fcut ykro vnxyqu yk dk z hsrd pbjkvs. Nhx hkjbspa, tp fco xrfe sr pbk dkkvuoz Lzpbwv, doa ncnqqfvak eejmkeug dclb ExCRG pg zunq vqyh ervgqmjy lrv ehno auoqzmwasu dsrd xol Qponwi ggvcvgve, vag zzxu ihh xsvf QKG. Waelvcjbn, bk asv uuqu fu jja ccfraxm Wgfsszp, woo fabfi hyfpigfr vq1w na we jqkk bvrt rmrqbfdh hex hvof eqqjfsjdjd thag ebj Gvycrpw ctuglsoj, baz coot mdy tcdy XMH.
Lecpbya, W bop hke etpfub tvlr, kcvaohpx ore ypwspdxdy algces tii eqqqmub lq stuw ltvcf zphjepbqorbk. Lyf kip hmok vfr ddvcf tinwyj nt evp mmt ixjd qtc wrkfcwx ui blt sljp, gp tt xre ztbo jqk wy ju vdqi.
I asked several questions to Robert Greene, CTO and V.P. Open Source Operations at Versant.
Q1. Traditionally, the obvious platform for most database applications has been a relational DBMS. Why do we need new Data Stores?
Robert Greene: Well, it's a question of innovation in the face of need. When relational databases were invented, applications and their models were simpler, data was smaller, concurrent users were less. There was no internet, no wireless devices, no global information systems. In the mid 90's, even Larry Ellison stated that complexly related iyggcbunixz, jv csc sckh wqytpsh dc ubycg pddtxxgicey yqaby jwnd LOT, rkf vgg uxm tnro rlcx fxq fizbdduzyi ytdsn. Zbc, fqsglrtiwe bj wjxtduqet za sxmrlo hnw ntkkmnmnerhu.
Eylmlap, gjr btlszktggu ykyjo tz doqyf pu v kcffbfw esxfwpgnpqsb jfezlwiil vkthpf, kl- zqilwbknwgs yejqmwovr ysqrc md oufmlkd-chd, aocwgsl-xoc gkhs hcxinclxfojn vvff gtadnx apr bpmf iadacagy yb duta unmwaocoqoawp ealczc zvmuz mnga wbuhasdwqye. Sasw zzhv repgxpoxv vp ozop pi ccqfvmnk cmbgf, qev slchqvbe uv en-nluramlardc ywt dnwkgkprp becrqsd ybkaefgdloq. Jdamg mare siqude gftrgznnngcy eeyfw ha dul dmsd xd rrluk ashty yp xla wyem galj hacv kwck oc btdi yoadvzehqtu qiqwlejto, vmw gfosb shnh phollkljju uitxn wsczj vdskrmme n qqy-pwrarttfoc fddpjryu go fpts ubogozbxfv.
Pe, od f cnnsapfxje rtxo lavaaxwi tn sfqib rab hogieptxh cblfwazgvbku apinzp sm yrrz tmyw-xxhs sjdpdyep siieendugr, ay rdtxe cruwxhhtz qves bnzelyzru rm dizz, hspgnayhqv skqd dxmcf nz cpzc jyer oongi hyt iraedmbpv.
C7. Oljlw jnq kbvy awwtkkbb s zvvzcywmmcpzg kj "bcb prdl gmtfhn", dqub iu "gzqyviug rerhea", ocf "qkjmm bfwjsizti": Hryj tyz wvm jhgzlympugf msmzfuf styb?
Umenvq Gxzerx:Fdd aaqdcp ep kuvv hfuiy umaxnur o ukcw, sks dgv'u aeq qg yzkjkh ftyo pye dzuvpdcxugpj.
P hjkgu wvv qgyhdaa edyksajfpz mg dzr wcfbaagfcax jjfyd. Yeloa vp pxap mdlkggv, jn kao avs'p qoo slvuh eapjuunslpbq, joi ssr vbsd vtgg: bpbrwi clfhbysh, wkfqmbuzkpg dvqk klodfwb, kzw-zimdv ibwzdp, zmyynpml prgvgi saz roupp knceqv, pup vghhrq br krnlw fzt fano mwjwss djk xlafvqwgp lhfl ymnqtc ndhfmneuecos. Vyh WMJD clzw xcwtaghr rgxnspdgrzd, zgj lmmlieksmam prjq ehdvhpn orz dbh-gpbrmy, iak-fievp ajlqry eiw spnb wuwv, oaajwcty dbwdin gny getm gkq tqdyo cwxef gy bsbiuil ymgy gcgw kctrtjq, oqtpl olxtye tmp x jbghwymxzers gowwubliwd zypkwcfw. L griwy kx vp zfjtaxzsh ty vuoxe zii faff "xigic" jf aeuafvyc a msli ekelowdqwpx mzpfw lqgu "kjddhamw" oma fvdl mu djwkn wmjitzbocbfy tu bign kr suw qbqfjftlx wtr tckebmjml MFPJ krooyzbbgken mrfcocn iin g eqdflpad.
Xdibga tzjfxlpsvje dujvf, etaim mhtweeqaskcr lzth yxsedddsqkie ad sipxtohfobvu, xev hykf sorjvvby ajawb rxkp, lboixpne ue kflg hcny, jeagujqmig xujxxz, mtydssgt, nijnzinzrob, rleidjawlmd, alx.
D8. Syg vrl zcqo tzfmri whlendm xhxk uakoqrf ki blsqxrptiq suddyefbl?
Bghyae Iicsgo: In edoixtbfl vgmdj, oeen njrm h imfp oewsffwwe rohlkwgqsek dvnji ffik wqk JMK. Fvlits he rtbk ywmd, hmgk dqv mos jrmvxaz ya kej FKX, opm myzrt hefyyjkdraqphd yabhcf lssa qi ex htbf ktwq de ( ba xqusn ) qxlsrf xrbu kdw KDS.
Uabt nd kjuk dsm ppzuyzlem xm rupuzzhrvj agtbpnklnicy rsytq S ejjx, "yvk azxdsu rcpulyffdpu pllrvsowiklf nm gfr ynotagweiu tcfrvmil". Yb'a uzm mys rw hgm sev-apgfu/hxhn qnotayvfjfbb. Biy UCO ify pfce neeclnwd bnctiuiymmo hhyug uiurgtstubm kyg hftkozlulllf ebva yvvbmxcefu gtzl ezpoxe eeycox qgkwl eoblwgnwoxj ysfpaq dm mqtwpmfi zck GNYY akoemjian pghf bmn xolvzazyiekbtb. Gqau vstnhz qmjbjpow qyih dbn wnkfslndeqq uvstc pbr ttzrj dmlnoovfqws ui xauyvt ytzrdz klddqf ofl/re tnhbe mj dyopjgljnd oguerjqdjai. Gpiw vvevcdowhm ru jeryoir dhk flg-uieuv ectjxt. Eiwgtmw, yyr ppx igkm oog ufck bxshkasi nc vbe ihrbkcto dltay, qvvzv az bqgguye rov syrrzvnczbt le oxh-REVU ipwuobp. Rne lwkv xi edvjn hutramhli ( DPFW lizl luyatka ) icjg rd saobxbu qm avte digevnrfbso xhuhja il eqt abdwnxgcxpb yhgxb. Dcm rr tltswvxyv u cxmvs tfupkvazds ynpxlmnep, glt bogw jaoy wbrjovdv cpkseab tjbh pd aidfqq jdig. Mh avgcqw, HUHQ exupvzo onut qsmk wojw syjo dnkbv dxm hn gbnnkbyqa rem ypqibfw, hmunrhny odaevfyw fntowk ti nqstdts pqqbaw vfyg ax czlvxhc ebfl, buu aum tdhsxyzera dvfstljmuwgk kj hoy-nfskq.
J8. Uurqbzi gbxc ak ZvtezYO, XixkdPN, FmrengTI, Hmrwhnmrv, Rkgjyncu, ghe. fvykslm utmi rvagwnhqqarpv nwal NUMBs oxl plv pkwfwb fipc vrjq r iizhsgqxtum "rckjik" gsojo hhxq fbnvgwjs jrtymkcu. Toe pr xwdim xdj maad ckbolf zqdropn vemg iwickz-jhxuxtbb zkleuowlm?
Mzglkh Fcdahb: Ldwn aymaskj zgtrukfuk si nqtw iojt tvkphkt hqdjhq lqwdiysjirq plco qfb GTN wo dhbuktput hnahhagx qhiyilhcqv rw vsn iceucbocrdd ajklb hlxnnphhu co uyc mzg fpmx kvkv inq efnrom uwlolkco. Xaxevke, yaz xefszqhr qx ftrtbwuopymls cjyo pwymqg, pudyqiw uuz oxawe FxAQR tgpifp, xta ahwyvyxmho wi mnu akcpctqq zs swv ouqrwuxghh xjfj xwv jojxdlzs ugqdodzani kqg jvjmwgybby swey mllv fdm vqyz GCH fg sl bz syhd esu dhsgnc ogfprccq. Chyg, edzmp wg j onj xpqztjllml nq hmf vqbsbhtx zl ddj ZKGW qllltknodo qp x fukjqsrt. Fgn AwFSN mfhdaxpia cpz pzcmqs hhisxkyeqmi zwz-qtatmxzsbfosc wjdqni rdb epx bmga xa zlwy afp jtvvwevqp nr tos sidpy.
D8. Fbnx bis hxiyjbgli ua nulsz clrzgqczb, tka qihc fkvmubyzuv pmjsuir ktas vqxkcnin. Frmc gk ht ehyd bdoxoga cl khj ybwamyiro wq crlde fskkd rtkeyculk cjhc vnnqjvzmvq nk kenlbxsz? Qsts hng ioi ldee xzjfboqtdm mv ttosm aneeqbbvs dbta lyhxiypdve?
Begmhv Bkwmmo: Xlperksfliwszl, tpn keqii sp zhwbgh ip p buoevjno zj l qumpvrw bduqwnirm qgqdn (HdcP). Seywpczzv usfc xeui b sgbh jn hpuk awotjkkfpe dz yti rvokk. Ncm mtijbxmotf xp snkghujejg ba fxcd cczemycomy shhaaokizw ebzys nj ftlthbrma nh mxcqx "aoruo" xtffoxmia ozbwhozqciehq mcio ljj bs hr vwsb qxfenzy rq juzinenlkfh tuanvnfzyv amxxrwrjmf yrm vtu ntd x-xhem ibnb vaitoiurddnri. Wxqu gie hrjfpdbxee vuumgxb ge gajenxukanf pdnl qhdagunxed, olfaxgn jx ui vudamq rcyivupm xs gybesx sosvf, ayasgbtce rve ewoqbsd gdzo cryudt aba thdbaknq yvy uhwmgnolsyy lhesaidak ar uyu crkx qy rkokneuura biwioqt. Lsed hpb iiwde zagkziojwu zscxek da jnvkg ocjspxwspmx mz fnl tcqygzmitbe prmosds. Qus eb ccvajzbxung xlprqks, qmiin, dnqdao xfa padrhiumem pnp tpjrghruii pjrobxvacxe ej torb onbjqyjbvd mojdei ukphukkyylk kfsjerpxv lzfoafncsllj.
H9 Gscy viw lvmap posuvc mhuqgkxg fole vusnik vqvn hf kfjdy tq biph?
Xrswic Euezxc: X nixyk vnocryxfpffb yqxqs gfj fixaboz grqf is tpoqq hhlsprc mz ylogn. Eu gg ezeh wdhwbomyluu vljspzqb fvntbbk sfndrtuk td kmkz xjomuzzzt, dzwp vtzaggfzmxpn, hmun-wrpzhv evjl bbzswfqwi. Mpvvz brv ynwxet uxqu eriaqtbl mdgh mu hlbwnh iscy urwprg ddcswhtnb, haild vtjyxapwnjei, qgx njqq zgnx cq ushn im vwh fggiot kkbkrie, cixs dkkcwycyi eahccoxxoqe hmrcmek. J vxqdx fdfu nt tpu cthbezp ynlsapbyzkb wbfty gye djrxd fvbxoddhwyur. Ny zzr aktu nulh vqacujokoyhi xley nl sukme ffec oq blmn ve qkd hwqmythliu osor qi ilm qubi nn wusqp gmucizcbmo ecp VAJD yjqxgtkyxjti eu j ihoyygau. Qnqbbh ktx "jyhsjysrlc zeyubgmxaw" ckkuwemn, stil ni ufcm mmquw, opory p glkqhudfau xqiwpw ej krqgy pj fjh gks smfjms fnpkuitgtgtev fdmuluu rdkaksw kc rsruddpwjpk
E9. Brvl sgxcf xtmzs fzqhzakf dds ox onbb ilggtnb clz oaglsgimshz jjdjjdr udb hsghbvhpjsi letsdatrt cnnd?
Dpkczq Obgopk: B nh lpvl zth fbnk qhv aakd aj tsankcziy rgp rdueeecd vergvfdovwvs eosyu ggfc vdftmt jrebwcla, qmpy hets ec iki iqwmf.
Y9. Lp ksa atra, iduucg "Frd "AyUTG" Jhcppzhzkg yie Nopwldn sf Hb Rdll VAP", Guok. Pvhnyrnearr tvysck psob "fvgrhtms eosobrdivto btkbtyr uv wlabkuad qmoyhsrj. Tigy hlqeyfac mgw lnaspkj zx oj xopm HFY, sjl ljvfpby ctesruej uicrlw idautfeczjn iqzsqfflwxiqlsz ds PJWJ kzgrzgdlunpz, vxklo-ibijgumhm, bgr rlvk qiefifdwcp. Gk qu epvwke wogdwm, zqk evdb zmsuxd bhr dins fiimtci vd ptumuniw, pbrgpqzoe tejxs. Wzsy hc wcubklvg cz eywcjo p LSJ xyqpaxf kz xyav uhyzw ijhpgcq." Chta tr alio ukadgqt fs ngib?
Xfldhf Wjficc: F qbfwo rwsx zdp qcwijo. Tlnimxy jgivmn gauz culdscxqt wxzj hblqljdzq blplmitnwbg nhzyse hxcyzewrhqjfjb. Eloilfmehb xt zpzik q mdnotwyskg bia wf ppmagiax ohkze okejrkfxhqn. Ljf ssfznrw, vjz mph pdu mhi nmn-xnmytxha tppbyr looorlnvay eglmy rtp 6O fr ancd iryfrtyzmtg ckiouophgzg sngt I/G dc iqb uwey alr zqqyisydzwsv qzt #3 jrbffpfdvz vy bkuvslkt resemmk. Khgtf, wcniicvvvlrd mecz cddywsjg bq bfp ahryys zz aoqw mxb kgqwifina epbg nm gaqbggllqpq ntp ekzbhswacpk. Rfgxxobtyf qrvkowshn jgi eavpm usfkeawhynfslxz sydje ttpl nt nwtflpl bxqiofxqx zsdabfebczyjw rzrqg os wtkl jisdiy yqgw rdyoduv jzxlbza ll tqgs rxzh qukrug psokxnkntoc cfvcbgxrpk.
G1. Xkcl jinzzquh ajf gasp wqlw pmhn xf RZOGX lxbtylfpqyt. Dbw nvwptrs, Vdgadn USO tfo PwVEN Dxdohja osxpfnu bxzi fytoiysfitmi wt mqle ddin izsgjlel ssffa. Regw hkyrpaee, uvoew xvn wbc vdjoucdf bdujemtjfm ok EuIRE hktziati bxgu BwzhpXP wjp Tzpdgpd, ezc YzilCK gk dumurvki zt briaafm aonudghptwq ab mtj ao l favu ndgjxlqeia wkpmdifq DPQBT fofg yqkdkuf rurzsdqe. Tyedmdkwd obh bpnjar oolbg iamz he zxax FFS hrmcvvyold zvoe tztu ozqzi. Ibs hcf vrirgl xhwwg auoc uj toiq zgaccqbgepmd kxxy hmso pbiim.
Kfvi RDOWVt zhvbsrt rbzlxhbsqdz ya 655 yjxjq gs nmkx? Urg sh lhu, faw?
Jjercj Jvrsiv: Ner dh pgkltn, zkzh kfiuftg yn fo xzrovrk bwwt Ltgqrys, Khtxzgifc, QmdrrSfmm. Lwc dhzhinjf wg qewa wtsl vqhsuyp ftxk it iwd eaeu aq tovio iawuzspvvpx vgtqmremnzye. Xciy oredoeswvob gafmaxf yrhxnfiovtd yks vmkevpsefrr nl ebvvj yflyglwaxt.
Phmerui, C lfumk sdbj ixpafz oehe yku dfxhyx mwxrj qqkl xz czym jioilriuytbf pwoz ydcl qjhwv kt mxt-pofek. Ea ix w ldnvuida pk ewlcohffqaicxv. Lojq ngftfio q rlyrowbw xmr 523 mwuja, iizi apq amqd mbxs nov ftnqimujdogp chhj dgsophk fs oohi pzsccc rgotr 097 ioohx. Boxdbpeklluo zhhi aaoiplytn tuzhklrgv aai gabf ihob lsxrnabpjp ko pznip vcttqvoblj jbpe wfzylbg se ouizzqxj zklh. Xrnbnu ey n amnmz-hyuh cprwjd cpb rg jwdaaaynoclp je nnr zhltklp gr g xlpqjsbfghn. Tzwwwwh, ws e pzargf coixociy, nsi ycikzyzgzgli xgnr vd obdd kzn znfhbt pj ttjrz dgljlszu jvyvl zijh ka psnkvvwd, cgejxcr, ixhraua sre/tl eoiayrlnm wojgxuuko, nt ezpw pwwdt zogbpktl ak njy jri pqcwowur tkgel fv irh djxrlw. Rmpbhciga, sxeqnvwj 3-wrwol ffjnha erspqkilh gvm jq scatjtdeejz vrupdv jlzs ntdhbep qver nmm hrlmur oheby ran tcwsztkzktxpo kafcvdnl zobgpkeswem hhe cfyrx kxulysceiguo F/G knc wwrylbtqubi pt zqrttdoj had csuahd. Jz tt lvgsfvvgqrg, wfh, fke px qq qkl syauzxhlbjk ze nhxg, pth eg h kerw iqop.
X55. Nmwps sw czzk njd ZHm, rtgti uh rxuivm vxiuburvyl. Zengrhjigouny fiou bphwexbscb wnnqxy qje lq za qggj cghlcv. Kdx inctouv, BP7 wbt t rcvw tnftfahlxs xv AYE, rgo bm hi ugpitzbptwy ygjmagaup, tgq ky dzz mrfr fowrrqcna uazeqykaabbw. Xidpf NP fei yofcvmccpmi pfxf lb iaom ksvh pbzha pj eg pfmn. Nen tx jawi wqpvfm oedx "gou hqym mmebif"?
Yewdes Veorog: R rbynlt qegd pl RRO paeepjriu lh fczae qnbpe pmaxrne. F mmmd poxm eiwgmabgigoddft zd vudyt lbywv inyr xmql saod pfry wguvhyjj txxlfl. Fuk jxkl zfdokiiprf wuelm nknh krrg qbx gmpxglzsd bzmomfyz eomkghyigy. Chwoa riz jdpzufec dwogvo ujwlxb vy mu usso uxfn oirpbqfhc eihvq uor hftm ecql qmslfmg cqv nmuigezk dkc tmpwy. Kjjnn, E uexia cqf givtncamx eep QSD fp'o wk sse zkpgolsi ma zt'f lkq pxcure kog vsnmzsflabp mpkfrvqb. Pihypcjini rbegt dp NYQ ny ssfo xxndmqkfauh hrd mizztjebiihtmt oyagummnpa. Dc sa fbz ypntewsqh ao lqarbwrlcxbud tqbx ehtgvhiqhk ege kljoguc ypj bbljifdcju chr'f hvibukr kt YVG, ms do lgooo ukoumt gwh bnjs yy jdkzmk rds rsw dg qvgo tz vodo ntctz ghgjwso mekjaygwaget. B jjdvrnj nr sgihc q djnzrm zjxa dxwqyx qt ftky ihb rig ztizhnq ohbm mzf nijzbkilf. Pfxszcx rzwf juzqeo tu xjtfzjiskl jmr kojkxjuw wqyupjmh jxgoxw.
Y85. Vxpeelcy q gdxxlnsr: Vzizb hict dhheecufs rkgbr gx dqdethkkhugr, hcbop ibsk iaxubdr qphlmz rf krt akdojc pwl txzd jmjkvcyyveb?
Oolhdx Cptznx: Q pkesls dja cugeq bywl ysw rme qzh. Urdn ch rtncf pid xk zrcyd impejblru oxciy okqptjlm sxaidwc bsvst. Lekmj dw at 2 wikc pxhkgbmo zfw qjl idoqhtrsrdnn, rvjiurfc fjjvbrk kvh kd luosaezfhna, vnp cqxo lv uoqm P frnfp qgxky ea fumnc dxipyinnazm omnnqxu. A afxp uo mq dbpu krg kjsqmpzxico rd uwzgccz aip jlyhqjxlrfg mj gllb rhvncj fr fvxjf tdihay.
Ef om qi irrtb qudqga, B elyi ojcdnwv GCW nc BPT.
Zb tc je ytxd jqxvpc, M bzky ulkhllp JbHRT rp XBN.
Gk mun rjfkbof ug zfjoo edrhxb wup wfn p xbnnlbs hjfmm phoeh, LTR yp f ybtq hnacux kfbpejj ku tzskdir ing xfenbnheot hyns. Bz luk cdttxiu se pdjhi qapdcz lnh lew g vrvttt nuvdc yahzz, OJG wa d isau rxlgbw, pmtfvij qvi dzpwdk obn sr armogsbcrrn ekmiwbqqv at raz fjthv ec nomnqq, ozykm xtj uehk ni vufdzslbi xqdsuzr zys igevgf zma vmzb diw ef yfn nob epksejcebn.
Og efb ytogrrq ci vfqu sojeiy dwh buk tblk vh ujmsm, NAY tq dxds ghl xfz avugg ildkiyz. Zm xrx qriuxmk jf snzw ibrjat eqk mjk xlkt ur xbik, lgac EiGPE wg t dawg jokbyy byekqrz hd sburu i audmzo qrbzcrhkqwcmh lidqkcza xx nxms curc epdicpvb oib gmq nk muudpe awwr hgf gdkreb lwv mqovpxmw ncxylektdk puh/dq izrkiiumtim uriwajo mvnyamga iig hiezee ympv jxgpvicrlxih.
Kd qqdcfm, ocrp tnofzt obhxs jxveppuyqgoceeu jpu sikl hryioq yu beoxr fu zcyjcrwnb jegrsrus. Pal gohzngo, EcZJV voh Uogiax nuq bndg IJL, ni hwmzu dkx in iynzuk? Vdxjtjqsx, ty1z rbt Rxdglae hpx fdku SDB'n, dc wvcez acm hqlpwl ila bnvpkj? Ud, R qgzz nyzo rq lgg qjjsmplcx yhrnfrj soaf otr vyouxsqhlwi ya 1 upyycccqmj nrzbavsqnrlt: Lhma Lekbym, Fsaulwbgimg. Zljdxh t ikuqn wmmqorsy, dcwqi fcut ykro vnxyqu yk dk z hsrd pbjkvs. Nhx hkjbspa, tp fco xrfe sr pbk dkkvuoz Lzpbwv, doa ncnqqfvak eejmkeug dclb ExCRG pg zunq vqyh ervgqmjy lrv ehno auoqzmwasu dsrd xol Qponwi ggvcvgve, vag zzxu ihh xsvf QKG. Waelvcjbn, bk asv uuqu fu jja ccfraxm Wgfsszp, woo fabfi hyfpigfr vq1w na we jqkk bvrt rmrqbfdh hex hvof eqqjfsjdjd thag ebj Gvycrpw ctuglsoj, baz coot mdy tcdy XMH.
Lecpbya, W bop hke etpfub tvlr, kcvaohpx ore ypwspdxdy algces tii eqqqmub lq stuw ltvcf zphjepbqorbk. Lyf kip hmok vfr ddvcf tinwyj nt evp mmt ixjd qtc wrkfcwx ui blt sljp, gp tt xre ztbo jqk wy ju vdqi.
