Armaflex insulation materials minimize the risk of corrosion under insulation
Outstanding results in the new CUI test of the TNO institute
Corrosion under insulation costs the global economy billions
Rust never sleeps – some 40 % of the world’s steel production is needed to replace parts destroyed by rust. The World Corrosion Organization estimates that corrosion damage costs the global economy 2.2 trillion US dollars annually – that is 3 % of the global gross domestic product. Some 45 % of the costs – around 1 trillion US dollars – arise annually in the oil, gas and petrochemical industry. According to a study by the US American ExxonMobil Chemical Company, 40 to 60 % of maintenance costs for pipework are due to CUI. And here the indirect costs as a result of downtime have not even been considered. Experts in the mineral oil industry assume that CUI is the main reason for unscheduled plant shutdowns and responsible for more downtime than all other causes together. In extreme cases leakages as a result of corrosion can even lead to fires or explosions, thus endangering human life.
Suitable insulation systems minimize the risk of corrosion
CUI is insidious: the processes occur hidden beneath the insulation and are often only discovered when extensive damage has already taken place. Insulation alone cannot safeguard plant components against corrosion, but appropriate insulation systems can effectively support corrosion protection. The choice of material decides whether the insulation minimizes the risk of corrosion or favours corrosion processes.
Armaflex in the TNO-ENDURES CUI test
The influence of the insulation systems used on the CUI risk is now gradually being acknowledged in the oil and gas industry. However, while there are recognized standards and procedures for assessing the performance of anti-corrosive treatments, as yet hardly any international standards address the influence of insulation materials on the CUI risk. The test method to assess a range of insulation materials which was developed by TNO-Endures (Den Helder, the Netherlands) for Shell could provide a basis. This methodology is widely recognized by the oil and gas industry and is seen by many specialists as the potential precursor to an official international standard.
In the standardized test Armaflex insulation materials were subjected to a worst case scenario: an insulated, unalloyed steel pipe with a medium temperature of 80 °C was continuously sprayed with warm saltwater. One half of the pipe was insulated with two layers of Armaflex sheets each 25 mm thick (case A). The other half of the pipe was prepared in the same way and then clad with a glass reinforced plastic (GRP) weather barrier (case B). To simulate a failure mode, in case A several holes were drilled through the entire insulation thickness. In the case B, on the other hand, the holes were only drilled in the cladding, the insulation remained undamaged. In both cases it was ensured that water could penetrate the insulation material. These artificial conditions, which are ideal for corrosion, were maintained for 6 months.
At the end of the test phase, the specimens were examined thoroughly. In case A corrosion had occurred as expected – however the processes were restricted to the immediate vicinity of the drill holes. There were no signs of corrosion in any other areas, including the entire underside of the pipe. The saltwater had obviously not spread and reached these regions. Expectations were surpassed again in the second case, in which the holes had only been drilled in the cladding. While the outer insulation layer was damp to touch at the end of the test phase, the inner insulation layer was completely dry. No corrosion was detected on the steel pipe. The Armaflex insulation had prevented moisture reaching the surface of the pipe.
In terms of physics, this remarkable result can be put down to the built-in vapour barrier of the closed-cell insulation material. The test demonstrated impressively that Armaflex minimizes CUI processes even under the harshest conditions. It must be emphasized again that the corrosion processes in this test were induced deliberately. Neither the ambient conditions nor the damage caused to the Armaflex material reflect real-life situations.
A detailed brochure on the study can be downloaded at: http://www.armacell.com/oilandgas/cui
Long service life of elastomeric insulation systems
The CUI test confirms the excellent results which have been achieved with Armaflex insulation materials throughout the world for decades. The closed-cell insulation material with low thermal conductivity and high resistance to water-vapour transmission provides plant components with long-term protection against condensation and energy losses. The highly flexible material fits snugly even around the most complex components and can be installed easily even under very difficult conditions on the building site. As is often noticed during maintenance work, plant insulated with Armaflex display no sign of corrosion even decades after its installation. Internal and external tests have shown that even after 20 years Armaflex still has the values guaranteed at the time of manufacture. To ensure a long service life of the insulation system, it is not only essential that the insulation thickness is calculated correctly and system-compatible accessories are used, but also that the materials are installed professionally following the manufacturers instructions.
Armacell is a world leader in flexible insulation foams for the equipment insula-tion market and also a leading provider of engineered foams. In the year 2014, the company with currently 2,600 employees generated net sales of EUR 452.2 million. With its 23 manufacturing plants in 16 countries on four continents, Armacell follows a strategy of internationalization. The com¬pany operates within two main businesses: the Advanced Insulation busi¬ness develops flexible insu-lation foam products for the insulation of mechanical equipment. The Engineered Foams business develops and mar¬kets light foams for use in a broad range of end-markets.
In addition to ARMAFLEX, the world’s leading brand for flexible technical insu-lation, Armacell offers thermoplastic insulation materi¬als, covering sys¬tems, fire protection and noise control solu¬tions as well as special foams for a multitude of industrial applications. In recent years, Armacell has devel¬oped new insulation systems for the oil and gas market, core foams for com¬posite materials, and low-smoke products that have set new standards in the industry.
Further information on Armacell can be found at www.armacell.com or www.armacell.com/oilandgas.